Dear 401(k) Participant -- An Open Letter

Dear 401(k) Plan Participant,

I hope you are doing well. I really do, but I am concerned about you. No, if you are one of those wealthy participants, I'm sure you'll be okay. It's the rest of you I'm worried about.

You got your statements around the end of last year and the markets were at near record highs. But, the Dow is down somewhere around 20% since then and the NASDAQ nearly double that. The fixed income part of your portfolio that most of you don't understand isn't doing very well either. Have you looked at those statements recently?

Let's look into the future. Do you plan to retire someday? Do you expect a source of regular lifetime income? You do? How much can that 401(k) buy you? Have you factored in the insurance company margins? How about the fees you're being charged by the recordkeeper for the plan and the fund manager? You haven't? Perhaps you should?

How about that lifetime income? Social Security is there, but it might not be the same program when you get to retirement age. 

What's that you say: you have a friend with a defined benefit (DB) plan? I know; you told them it was foolish to factor that into their choice of an employer, but they're still not upset with their choice, are they?

I understand that a year ago, you were contributing 10% of your pay to your 401(k) plan. That's great. But with inflation, you don't seem to be able to do that anymore? Oh, you maxed out your credit cards so that you could contribute to your 401(k) and now you can't pay them down? And, you can't afford to go out, but you can't afford groceries, and you can't handle your credit card debt? Where did you say that lifetime income was coming from?

How about that friend who took the job you recommended against? You know; that job with a pension. That's a pension her employer pays for. You say your friend has been contributing a steady 5% of pay to their 401(k) and feels absolutely fine about retiring someday? Your friend isn't worried about lifetime income just because they have a good DB plan? 

Amazing!

And that house you just overpaid for? But, you got a great teaser rate on your Adjustable Rate Mortgage. Oh, what was that? The rate resets after one year and it doesn't look good. But you told me it was okay because you read you can tap into your 401(k). Something that I think you called a hardship withdrawal?

So, the markets are depleting your 401(k), you're depleting it, and you can't afford to contribute to it anymore? Doesn't that bother you? Why isn't your friend with the DB plan losing sleep at night like you are?

What's that you said? You're going to be parents? The medical costs for childbirth are going to eat away at your HSA balance? And, then there are diapers and you're afraid you'll have to buy formula? Those are all expensive, aren't they?

How are you doing with those lifetime income projections?

Don't you wish you had a DB plan?

How are you doing with your credit card debt? Your mortgage? Your weekly food bills? Your discretionary income for fun? You mean you had to give up saving for retirement?

Don't you wish you had a DB plan?

Regretfully, but I told you so,

John