Showing posts with label Bonus. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Bonus. Show all posts

Tuesday, February 16, 2016

Compensating Executives in a "Challenging" World

The rationale has always gone something like this: if you don't compensate your executives at least equal to their peers and if you don't reward their performance, you will never have a top tier executive group and your company will not succeed.

Is that statement true? Is part of it true?

We're getting much closer to finding out. The big news this proxy season is from shareholder proposals on executive compensation. That's right -- since Say-on-Pay votes are non-binding, shareholder groups are looking to force companies to put components of executive compensation to a binding shareholder vote.

Before getting into a few details, let's understand how most companies are reacting. It's not surprising, but as a group, large corporations do not think their shareholders understand executive compensation. They are seeking to keep these votes off of their proxies. As a precursor to doing so, they request what is known as a "no-action letter" from the Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC). In brief, when a government agency issues a no-action letter, it assures the requestor that it will not take action on a given issue. So, when a company seeks such a letter from the SEC, the company is asking the SEC to confirm that it will not take action, for example, for a failure to place a particular item in its definitive proxy.

One of the most ardent submitters of executive compensation proposals is the largest American labor union, the AFL-CIO. In a statement, the AFL-CIO said, "We opposed compensation plans that provide windfalls to executives that are unrelated to their performance."

On its surface, that seems very prudent. But, it may be a bit trickier in practice.

What makes compensation related to performance? How does one define performance? Is compensation as expressed in the Summary Compensation Table? Is it cash only? Does it include equity? Does it include the (proxy-includable) value of deferred compensation?

Here is how it would strike me.


  • Base pay is not related to performance. But, generally, to the extent that such pay is deductible to the employer under Section 162(m) ($1 million pay cap), some observers will not consider it to be egregious. On the other hand, in today's world of pay ratios and calls for increases in rank and file wages, other observers will ask that it be capped at some multiple of either the median pay for the entire company or even that of the lowest-paid employees of the company.
  • Bonuses are theoretically related to performance. To the extent that the criteria used to evaluate executive performance and by extension, executive bonuses, are appropriate, so should those bonuses be. To play devil's advocate, however, if an executive knows how her bonus will be calculated, she may take inappropriate risks (for the company) in order to maximize the expected value of her bonus. Similarly, she may find ways to accelerate certain items into the fiscal year in question while deferring others until the next year. 
  • Long-term incentives are [nearly] always performance based. In today's world, it is expected that those incentive payouts will be based on the achievement of a set of goals related to metrics deemed appropriate for that executive. Often, there are circuit breakers (elements that if the executive fails to meet a pre-established minimum level of performance, he will not receive a payout or that part of a payout at all). But, long-term incentives are often paid in company equity. This means that compensation will, to a large extent, be tied to share price. As we know, however, share price is not always tied to corporate performance. On any given day, share price may be influenced by such as the state of peace or war in the Middle East, a speech given by the President of the United States, or the rise or fall of housing starts during the last month. 
  • What about deferred compensation (here I am referring to traditional deferred compensation plans, either defined benefit or defined contribution)? It's rarely performance based. Theoretically, the company is paying an executive less today for a promise to give them some of that pay in the future. What sorts of plans should be challenged? If an executive voluntarily defers some of their compensation and it grows at a rate tied to some broadly investable index, is that okay? Suppose she has a DB SERP that looks just like the broad-based plan (qualified plan), but without limitations applicable to qualified plans. Institutional Shareholder Services (ISS) is generally fine with this, but major labor unions may not be. And, if that SERP looks very different from qualified plans, even if there is a good reason for it, this may be a situation where no institutional shareholders are satisfied.
What should Boards of Directors and their Compensation Committees do about all of this? ConocoPhillips shareholders are asking that the Compensation Committee develop a program to determine which portions of a bonus should be paid immediately, which portions should be deferred, and what adjustments should be made to those deferrals based on performance.

Perhaps this has some merit. If it does, however, it's a bit of a nightmare for people who need to figure out how to make such a plan 409A-compliant and for those who need to administer FICA tax payments.

On the other hand, if adjustments are to be made based on performance, can't the same executive who is able to manipulate performance metrics in the LTI scenario described above also find a way to manipulate them here? Where there are objective formulas, there are smart people who can figure out how to game the system. Where there are subjective evaluations, Boards will be accused of pandering to the executives of the companies.

More than ever, the Compensation Discussion and Analysis (CD&A) will be very key. Explaining why the mix of objective and subjective factors was chosen can go a long way to appeasing large shareholders. Explaining how levels of compensation were chosen is a must. And, for the first time, we may see companies rationalizing their levels of executive pay as compared to rank and file pay.

With all of these challenges to executive compensation, these are challenging times for Compensation Committees.

Thursday, November 12, 2015

CFO Priorities and Benefits and Compensation

CFO magazine did their annual survey of the priorities of chief financial officers recently. I read their article summarizing the findings from the survey and considered what this might mean for benefits and compensation.

Before I go on to my main topic, however, I need to bring up a few of the issues that I found near the bottom of the article. Three priorities that the article highlighted were written communication, networking with peers and presenting to large groups. Frankly, these are not just CFO priorities; they should be priorities for every professional in our 2015 world, and I was absolutely thrilled to see written communication in the list.

Returning to the main points of the article, I point out some of the top priorities that are more day-to-day for CFOs.


  • Precision and efficiency in cash forecasting
  • Budgeting
  • Balanced scorecards
  • Margins
  • Risk management
  • Performance management
Additionally, and in many cases perhaps more important, but less relevant for this blog is cybersecurity.

Let's also consider what some of the main elements of traditional benefits and compensation packages look like (with some grouping at my discretion).

  • Health and wellness benefits
  • Retirement benefits
  • Other traditional welfare benefits
  • Feelgood benefits
  • Base pay
  • Short-term incentives (bonus)
  • Long-term incentives (often equity)
Health benefits are now essentially a requirement. Either you provide them or pay a fine under the Affordable Care Act (ACA). But, companies have lots of techniques that they can use to control costs. Popular today are high-deductible health plans (HDHP) where oftentimes, companies contribute fixed amounts to health savings accounts (HSAs) to help employees pay for costs up to those deductibles. Among the major advantages of these designs are that companies do a much better job of locking in their costs. In other words, more costs are known and far fewer costs are variable or unknown. 

On the subject of retirement benefits, I'm going to give you a shocker. In matching those CFO priorities, the single worst sort of retirement plan that a company can sponsor is a traditional 401(k) plan with a company match. That's right -- it's the worst! Why is that? In a 401(k) plan, the amount of money that a company spends is almost entirely dependent upon employee behavior. If you, as an employer, communicate the value of the plan, employees defer more and that costs you more. Most companies budget a number for their cash outlay for the 401(k) plan. Very few, in my experience, look at potential variability. One that does and that I worked with on this a number of years ago, estimates that between best case and worst case, that the difference in their cash outlay could be in the range of several hundred million dollars. That is a lot of money.

So, what is better?

Believe it or not, I can come up with lots of rationales (much beyond the scope of this post) for why having a defined benefit plan as a company's primary retirement vehicle is superior to using a 401(k) plan. Understand, I'm not talking about just any DB plan. But, the Pension Protection Act of 2006 (PPA) opened the door for new types of DB plans that either were not expressly permitted previously or, in other cases, that were generally not considered feasible. Think about a cash balance plan using a market return interest crediting rate with plan investments selected to properly hedge fluctuation. Cash flow becomes predictable. Volatility generally goes away. Budgeting is simple. The plan can be designed to not negatively affect margins.

I may write more in a future post, but for now, suffice it to say that this design that has not yet caught on in the corporate world needs some real consideration.

How about compensation? 

Base pay is the easiest to budget for. If you do have a budget and commit to not spending outside of that budget, base pay is pretty simple to keep within your goals. 

Incentive compensation is trickier. While many organizations have "bonus pools", they also tend to have formulaic incentive programs. So, what happens when the some of the formulaic incentives exceeds the amount in the bonus pool? Either you blow your budget or you make people particularly unhappy. There is little that will cause a top performer to leave your company faster than having her calculate that her bonus is to be some particular number of dollars only to learn that it got cut back to 70% of that number because the company didn't budget properly.

Perhaps it is better to assign an individual a number of bonus credits based on their performance and then compare their number of credits to the total number of credits allocated to determine a ratio of the total bonus pool awarded to that individual. After all, isn't the performance of the company roughly equal to the sum pf the performances of individuals and teams? And, if the company has a bad year, isn't it impossible that every individual and team exceeded expectations? Be honest, you know that has happened at lots of companies and the companies don't know what to do or how to explain it.

There is lots more to be said, but I want to keep it brief for now. If you have questions on some of the specifics, please post here or on Twitter or LinkedIn in reply to my post or tweet. And, if you have one of these areas on which you'd like to see me expand in a future post, let me know about that as well.

Wednesday, November 30, 2011

Are You Sleeping? Who is Managing the Compensation Risk?

Risk management used to be viewed with a somewhat jaundiced eye. It was something that the geeks did. I know, at your company, you just didn't need it because you understood your business better than some guy with a fancy degree, a pocket protector, and an HP-12C.

While companies had full-time risk managers and even risk management departments before then, this mad science really came to the forefront in the early 2000s. Suddenly, companies were seeing that risks that they had taken, especially in the area of leveraging themselves perhaps a bit too much, were starting to bite them in their proverbial hind quarters.

With that, the CRO or Chief Risk Officer, became the new sought after geek. Here was a person with specialized training who could look after the store, so to speak. If the CRO approved, then the CEO and CFO had a special comfort that all would be well.

Yes, CROs, as a group, do have specialized training. They tend to be smart people who can model the risks of a veritable cornucopia of corporate transactions. But, even the smartest person doesn't have the capacity to consider every possible risk. Sometimes, they are just not aware of certain risks. Sometimes, the other departments take actions without consulting the CRO and his staff because they just don't think the particular decisions has a risk potential that hits that threshold.

Perhaps that department was Human Resources. I know, you think I am wrong; by the early 2000s, the Risk Management Department was heavily involved in working with pension plans. Well, I am focused on a different part of Human Resources here, the part that develops compensation programs.

Way back when, you know, about 25 years ago, a typical bonus program worked something like this. Everyone in the program had a target bonus -- some percentage of their base pay. To go with that target bonus, you had a set of goals. They were, in theory, set up so that you had a roughly equal chance of exceeding your goals or of falling short. And, your bonus was typically capped, on the upside at twice your target and on the downside at zero.

Ah, theory, what a wonderful concept.

Picture yourself as a manager. You have three employees to review for their performance in 2011. Let's call them Larry, Moe, and Curly. Larry has always been a star performer. Each year, he has exceeded expectations. But, in 2011, Larry did not have a good year. He fell short of every goal. But, somewhere in your mind, although you can't quite put your finger on the exact cause, you think there must have been extenuating circumstances. You are sure that Larry will have a good year in 2012, and what's more, you don't want to lose him to a competitor. So, on your 1 to 5 scale with 5 being the best, you grade Larry as a 3.5. You tell him that he is being rewarded for a prolonged period of high performance, but that he needs to step it up in 2012.

Moe has always been your man in the middle. He's been a consistent performer, always meeting goals, but rarely exceeding them. But, Moe has those intangibles. They are not in his goals, but you just have to reward him because he makes everyone around him better. In 2011, Moe exactly met his goals, but because of that special something, you gave him a rating of 3.5.

Curly has been your problem child. Each year, he has been the laggard of the three, but you have kept him around both because the team has been meeting its goals (due mostly to Larry) and because of his wonderful sense of humor. Curly keeps you laughing and he is just so likable. Finally, for the first time, in 2011, Curly beat his goals. You gave him a rating of 3.5

Let's look at what happened. Your team exactly met its goals. Yet, you awarded each team member with a rating that gets them a bonus of 125% of target. Hmm?

And, then in another year, business was really good. You find out that the bonus pool is going to be really big. Curly had another very good year. You give him a rating of 4.5. Moe had a better year than Curly, and you know that somehow, Moe also contributed to Larry's success this year, so you give him a 4.9. But, Larry, oh Larry, had the year of a lifetime. If Moe got a 4.9, there is no rating that does Larry's year justice, so you take it up the line to get Larry a bonus of 3 times target. And, because business was so good, it gets approved.

But, the next year, the economy goes into the tank. Nobody meets their goals, and in fact, the company lost money. It would like to have a negative bonus pool, but that can't happen. And, all of your employees tried really hard, so you want to give them something. You beg to your superiors just as every manager is doing, but where will the money come from?

As time went by, companies survived this strange concept where everyone got a bigger bonus than they really deserved. So, it became accepted that there was really no upside limit to bonuses, at least not for the top producers.

But, I digress for a brief commercial. If you haven't read Michael Lewis's book, The Big Short, then you should. To a large extent, it shows how having no upside limits to incentive payouts encourages absolutely ridiculous risk-taking. Without giving away the whole book, people were making and taking 12-figure risks on bets that they didn't understand. Hmm?

And, they were being rewarded for it. People who had budgeted incentive payouts in the range of several hundred thousand dollars were suddenly getting 8-figure payouts. They were betting on these wonderful instruments known as credit default swaps, and most of them were taking what turned out to be the wrong side of the bet. But, the risk management people didn't understand them either. In fact, very few people did.

So, now we are really in 2011, very close to the end of it, in fact. Managers with explicit incentive compensation plans will be facing the same issues all over again. Far more visibly, Compensation Committees will be facing the same issues all over again.

Let's peek in at a deliberation as the Compensation Committee decides how much of an incentive payout to give to CEO Lou Abbott and CFO Bud Costello. The company didn't have a great year, but neither did any of their competitors. And, Abbott and Costello, everyone knows, are legends in the industry. We really can't afford to lose either one of them. Last year wasn't too good either. We really can't risk losing them over a bad incentive payout. Let's give them something extra this year and we'll go harsher on them the next time their scheduled payout would be huge. [Hopefully, this behavior isn't occurring in any real Compensation Committees, but you never know.]

Do you think the Compensation Committee will remember?

So, here's the deal. In a bad year, bonuses in total may be more than the company can afford because they can't afford to pay out that little and risk losing people over it. In a mediocre year, bonuses in total may be more than the company can afford because everybody had something positive about their year. And, in a great year, the risk-takers won and they will get bonuses so big that the company will pay out more than it can afford.

And where is the Risk Management Department to ask who is managing the compensation risk?