Showing posts with label Equity Compensation. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Equity Compensation. Show all posts

Wednesday, September 25, 2013

A Service to Go with a Sad Story

I am going to pitch a service here that all employers should consider. If you are spending money to provide additional benefits for your executives, that money should go to them and not to the government.

Sometimes a good idea comes out of a sad story. And, I'm happy to report that in this case, it's sad because a company wasted money providing a generous benefit for its executives and then didn't tell the executives the pitfalls, but it's not sad in the context of someone going bankrupt or suffering a tragedy.

I got a call yesterday afternoon from someone who found me on the internet, probably through this blog. His wife is a participant in a SERP. Her employment with the company ended in July (I don't know how or why, I just know that it ended).

In early 2007, the wife received a communication from her employer. It told her that her SERP was being split into two pieces -- a 409A-grandfathered piece and a non-grandfathered piece. This was a not uncommon strategy. In addition, the non-grandfathered piece had a default payment of a lump sum of the present value of the accrued benefit payable six months after termination. A participant could elect a different form and or timing of payment (within limits defined in the plan). All of this is very normal in the world of SERPs post-409A.

Apparently, that is all the communication told her. It didn't explain the complexities of 409A. From what I could gather, her employer didn't want to give too much information because they were worried about potential litigation. So, they probably figured that giving no guidance at all meant that they gave no incorrect guidance.

When I answered the phone, the unhappy husband told me that he and his wife assumed that she could change her option when she terminated. So, she accepted the default and went on her merry way. Now, she will be receiving a lump sum that they don't really need right now and paying about half of it to various governments in the form of taxes.

Here's the idea. An employer could choose to go all the way or just do part of this.

Get an outsider like me who understands executive rewards and the 409A and other tax implications to help communicate to your executive group. In what I would term a perfect world (assuming that the employer chooses to not do the communication themselves), here is what would be entailed:

  • Provide the outside consultant with the plan provisions and data for all the parts of the rewards package that you would like covered (SERP, deferred compensation plan, equity compensation, cash compensation, severance, change in control, etc.)
  • Invite your executive group to a meeting. In that meeting, the outside consultant presents to the group generically on those elements of the rewards package. In that meeting, each executive, will get a summary/informal statement of their rewards package showing values and costs. The executives will place greater value on their rewards packages when they know how much they are worth and how much you are spending on them.
  • With signed waivers (consulting, not legal, tax or accounting advice), allow executives to have individual meetings with the outside consultant after the group meeting. Let them ask questions about what they can change and when, what are their options, and what are their restrictions?
  • These meetings can cover as much or as little of the executive rewards package as you would like, but the idea is to use the money that you are spending on executives for executives, not for the government.
Consider it. Let me help.

Tuesday, April 10, 2012

How About Paying With Debt?

If you follow proxy statements or outrageous headlines, you'll know that Timothy Cook, CEO of Apple got nearly $400 million in compensation last year (I use the word got because he didn't actually receive that much, but he did receive equity compensation with a calculated value nearly that number). The headlines have made it even worse. With the run-up in Apple stock, that $400 million in equity is now worth more than $600 million.

Is Mr. Cook worth that much to Apple and its shareholders. I doubt it. But, how does one calculate how much Mr. Cook is worth to shareholders. Is it based on the shareholder value that he adds? That would be nice, but how do you calculate that? Stern Stewart used to (maybe they still do) like the idea of compensating executives based on Economic Value Added (EVA). EVA, in my opinion, was very precise, but not very exact.

At the end of the day, we don't know the exactly right way to compensate a chief executive. It's not an exact science. Here is what we do know. Institutional Shareholder Services (ISS) and other similar proxy evaluation firms would like for executives to be paid not above the median for their peer group. They would like for an executive's incentive payouts to be tied to performance and linked to shareholder return. They would like for no component to be excessive.

That's all nice. But, here are a few facts ... got that, these are FACTS!


  • Unless all peer groups are homogeneous and all CEOs within a peer group are paid at the median, some CEOs will be paid above the median of their peer group. The mathematical proof is simple, but will be left to the reader as my old math texts used to say.
  • Some CEOs are better than others.
  • Within a peer group, different CEOs have and should have different sets of goals.
  • Some companies within a peer group will be more mature than others in their life cycle.
  • No two companies within a peer group are exactly the same.
That's all nice, but where am I going with this?

Between outcries from advocacy groups, law changes pushed through Congress, and general screams from all who seem to care, executive compensation, especially for chief executives, has become very largely equity-based. That way, their compensation is tied to the returns of the owners of the company. In the case of Apple, maybe this is appropriate (maybe tends to imply maybe not as well). If you look at Apple's balance sheet, you are blown away by assets, including cash, but you don't see a company mired in debt.

That may not be representative of corporate America though. Suppose we look at a company that like many others today is mired in debt. I'm not going to pick one in particular, but if you've read this far, then I feel confident that you could. What happens if we paid the chief executive of the company partially in debt? What would this do?

When a company carries too much debt, it's credit rating tends to go down which makes the value of its debt go down. Doesn't this imply that a heavily debt-laden company should not take undue risk? (Yes, I understand that for a heavily-depressed company, the only option for survival may be to take seemingly undue risk, but that's not the point here.) Well, if the chief executive's compensation falls when he or she subjects the company to undue risk, perhaps that will be a warning to lay off the heavily leveraged bets. Under a structure like that, I can think of lots of chief executives who failed the company (and shareholders and debtholders), but ran off to retirement heaven as extraordinarily wealthy men, who wouldn't have fared so well. Perhaps their shareholders and debtholders would have done better if those chief executives had taken less risk.

I'm not saying that this is THE right way, or even part of the right way for every company, but think about it. Suppose the CEOs of all the failed banks had been paid with debt ... just suppose.